Duck Farming
While duck meat might not be as commonly consumed as other meats, products like jackets, pillows, and blankets can be filled with down, which comes from the same animals who are being killed for meat. This article will be focusing on the duck meat industry, how it operates, the environmental impacts, and health impacts.
About Ducks
Everyone loves seeing cute little ducklings running around, but we don’t often think about them as conscious or sentient individuals. The more we understand the thought processes and abilities of ducks, the more likely we are to see the cruelty of the duck meat industry, which denies them of their natural behaviours.
Ducks are maternal
Adult ducks care for their young in a number of different ways. Ducklings are unable to thermoregulate and require a parent to warm them with their wings and body. Parent ducks protect them from rain, hail, snow, sunlight, and wind, as well as predators. Ducklings also rely on their mothers to teach them what they can eat, where their home is, and how to survive [1]. Ducklings stay with their mothers for 40-60 days, before they fly off to make their own brood [2].
Ducks have abstract thoughts
Ducklings are smarter than we give them credit for. Research has shown that they have abstract thoughts, something that was only thought possible with primates and other highly intelligent animals! They have the ability to discriminate between abstract relational concepts without any reinforcement or training [3].
On farms, ducks are given no enrichment, leaving them bored and frustrated, and as a result they can become aggressive toward one another.
Ducks have a language
While most people are aware that ducks quack, they may not know that they whistle, coo, grunt, and yodel, which varies from soft to very loud calls. These verbal communications may be to call for their mate, to find their babies or signal them to come, or to warn them of predators and threats. They also communicate with touch and visuals, such as pumping their heads up and down [4].
The Industry
Around the world, approximately 11 million ducks are killed every single day. That equates to over 4 billion a year [5]. Australia’s duck meat industry is unfortunately growing, currently sending around 8-million to slaughter every year [6]. Commercial operations vary, with farms having between 6,000 and 50,000 ducks at one time [7].
Standards and Welfare
The following information is regarding ducks farmed in Australia, however, it is relevant to duck farming overseas. In Australia, there are no mandatory skills required to operate a duck farm [7], and ducks are raised in similar conditions to broiler chickens.
Breeder Flock
As with chickens, duck eggs are imported from overseas, and once hatched and quarantined, these ducks, known as ‘grandparent flocks’, go to breeder farms. The majority come from the Grimaud Duck, from France, and the Cherry Valley Duck from the UK [8 DOC]. The fertile eggs of the grandparent breeder ducks then go to a hatchery and become the ‘parent’ flock of the ducks killed for human consumption [7]. The parent flock is placed in sheds at 2 weeks of age for the next 26 weeks. After they have reached sexual maturity, they are moved into the breeding sheds, where they will lay for a maximum of 16 months. At just 18 to 23 months old, the grandparent and parent flocks are slaughtered and replaced, and the cycle continues [9 PDF].
Confined Living
Bill Trimming
Farmed without water
Flooring
Genetic Altering
Feed
Slaughter
Animal Liberation Exposés
In 2012-2013, Animal Liberation exposed Pepe’s Ducks false and misleading advertising to consumers [21]. After receiving proof of the ducks being farmed inside sheds with no water, and an investigation by the ACCC, Pepe’s Ducks was fined $400,000 for false, misleading, and deceptive conduct [22]. Shortly after, Animal Liberation had the ACCC investigate Luv-A-Duck for their false claims, and they were fined $360,000 for misleading advertising [23].
The Environment
Like all other animal farming practices, the factory farming of ducks is having a negative impact on the environment.
Land and Resources
Natural land must be cleared for the sheds and the feed of farmed ducks, as with all farmed animals. Clearing the land destroys natural habitats for wild animals and destroys the structure of the soil. Ducks require approximately 2.15kg of food to produce just 1kg of duck meat [24], or around 8kg during their life [25]. It is estimated that 4,325 litres of water is used to produce just 1 kilogram of duck meat [26]. While these amounts are less than those for cattle, pigs, and sheep, ending our consumption of these animals will still save natural land, water, and feed.
Waste and Pollution
Animal agriculture is responsible for creating millions of tonnes of waste every year. This waste is used to fertilise crops, however, it can have devastating impact on the environment [9]. Duck waste contains nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, and heavy metals, like zinc, copper, chromium [27]. When used on crops, the nutrients enter the air, water, and ground.
Due to the high amount of waste, duck farms are a source of air pollution and odour, which attracts flies, rodents, and other unwanted animals. Ammonia, hydrogen sulphide, and volatile organic compounds pollute air quality [28]. Just 1 kilogram of duck meat produces 5.4 kilograms of CO2 [27].
Our Health
Your Health
While duck meat does contain protein, so does a range of plant produce (plants also have an array of nutrients, vitamins, and minerals). A study, albeit small, found that both red and white meat increase LDL cholesterol (the ‘bad’ cholesterol), by 6-7%, with both high and low saturated fat intake. This spike in cholesterol can increase the risk of heart disease by several percent [29].
Despite being sold as a “healthy” meat choice, ducks on farms have a high risk of illness, due to poor husbandry, their inability to clean themselves, and the prevalence of faeces. Many suffer from Anatipestifer Disease, which is primarily thought to occur through trauma to the delicate feet. It causes diarrhoea, lethargy, respiratory, and nervous system issues. Others suffer from dyspnoea (trouble breathing), ocular and nasal discharge, coughing, sneezing, tremors of the head and neck, weakness and incoordination [30 PDF]. When ducks die before reaching the slaughterhouse, they enter the food system as feed for farmed animals. The Department of Agriculture, Fisheries, and Forestry allow for same species feeding (forced cannibalism) – meaning, ducks are being fed ducks, along with other rendered animals and their body parts (chickens, hoofs, hide, fish, and wool etc) [31].
Public Health
With the domestication of animals came a range of diseases that most likely wouldn’t have impacted humans otherwise – for example, SARS, Ebola, mad cow, bird flu, whooping cough, typhoid fever, and influenza [32]. Influenza started as an intestinal bug in ducks. It sits in their intestinal lining and as they secrete, it enters the water and is consumed by another duck, continuing the cycle. When ducks were mixed with land-based avian species – chickens – it infected them, and then mutated to find a new way to spread, eventually mutating to infect humans [33]. Keeping ducks in unnatural, cramped conditions, is providing conditions for viruses to potentially mutate. One of the key reasons that ducks are farmed in sheds is to reduce the risk of contracting diseases from wild birds.
Duck farms can suffer from outbreaks of diseases such as salmonella, Escherichia coli, and Pasteurella multocidia, but these are quickly brought under control. The most serious disease for intensively-reared ducks on multi-age farms is Rimerella (Pasteurella) anatipestifer which causes tremors and incoordination [34].
People who work or live near poultry farms are at risk of developing respiratory issues. Workers are exposed to high ammonia levels and dust, which is made up of feed, fecal particles, feather barbules, skin debris, spores, and bacterial garments [35]. They are at risk of chronic bronchitis, asthma, runny noses, and irritated eyes [36 37]. Living near poultry farms is associated with an 11% increased risk of community-acquired pneumonia, possibly resulting from changes in the upper respiratory tract microbiota composition in susceptible individuals [38, 39].
What’s Next?
For the animals, the planet, and ourselves, we need to work together to change our food system. These sentient beings deserve to live a life free from human harm, where they can exhibit their natural behaviours.